Freakanomics by Steven D. Levitt and Stephen J. Dubner
I’m probably one of the last people in america to read this book.
I read it this past weekend while we were up visiting my parents in
Kentucky. I had given it to my father for Christmas and he had spoken
glowingly of it; This made it significant, because he is one difficult
person to shop for.
It’s certainly a short read, as evidenced by the fact that I read it in
bits and pieces between Friday morning and Saturday night.
It’s an interesting tome. Most of the critiques of this book seem to
center around a lack of rigor or failure to demonstrate in detail the
analysis behind the assertions. But given that it’s written as a “pop
economics” book for mass appeal, this doesn’t really surprise or bother me
overmuch.
While I wouldn’t take any of the conclusions as gospel truth, it’s got a
bunch of fun stuff to think about, which is probably all it was meant to
be.
The Freakonomist
I thought ‘Freakonomics’ was fascinating, although I’d like to see someone like ‘The New Republic’ or ‘The New York Review of Books’ put some of his findings to the test. The Roe v. Wade/crime rate chapter is especially interesting. I like the way it holds liberal (Brady Bill) and conservative (Guiliani laws) to the same standard.
Re: The Freakonomist
Yeah, it did seem fairly balanced… and the stuff is fascinating to think about.
I went looking for critiques of the book and there were plenty, but they either didn’t make any sense or began with the caveat “Now, I haven’t read his source material…”
So, yeah, New Republic, where are you? Somebody get out there and confirm or deny his findings with data!